Interactive Musings

Interactive Musings

The Evil Impulse

Posted on August 27, 2012 at 11:50 PM

THE EVIL IMPULSE

08/27/2012

 

Evil impulses are inherent in human nature, as are good impulses.

 

In Hebrew, the evil impulse is called yetzer ra, and the good impulse is called yetzer tov.  Acknowledging the existence of both impulses is essential to Jewish thought – as it is to Freudian psychoanalysis.  Freud postulated two drives inherent to human nature, eros and thanatos, a sexual drive and an aggressive drive. 

 

In religious tradition, the world is seen in terms of good and evil.  From a psychoanalytic standpoint, the impulses are not evaluated, nor judged for their moral or ethical essence.  Rather, they are acknowledged as aspects of human nature to be recognized, understood, and made conscious.

 

In Judaism, the emphasis is on choice.  Each person has the capability to choose to follow an evil impulse or a good impulse. 

 

In psychoanalysis, the emphasis is on self-knowledge, so that we do not act from the unconscious.  Rather, we become aware of our feelings, thoughts, conflicts, attitudes, desires, and memories, and our awareness creates opportunities for choices.  Rather than continue to be motivated by unconscious pressures, we have more personal power, the ability to act with self-awareness.

 

In Jewish thought, the evil impulse is selfishness without awareness of or concern for the impact of one’s actions on others.  Therefore we can understand sadism and violence as corruptions of the evil impulse, in a sense, extreme perversions of the evil impulse.  The evil impulse does not have to be denied, it has to be mitigated by loving concern, a kindly awareness of the experiences of others. 

 

Both Judaism and psychoanalysis offer the possibility of resolution of conflict, of reconciliation of one’s own selfishness, one’s own evil impulse, with one’s desire to think of ourselves as good.

 

Psychoanalysis enables us to understand that our desire to do something forbidden, something harmful, can be experienced, felt deeply, and transformed into something commensurate with the good impulse, without betraying our core self.

 

Our challenge is to embrace the evil impulse, to embrace and experience the feelings that give impetus to the evil impulse.

 

An important aspect of human nature is our capacity for self-reflection, and self-judgment.  One religious tradition calls self-reflection the Witness; psychoanalysis calls self-reflection observing ego.  Religions call self-judgment conscience; psychoanalysis calls self-judgment superego.  As we become aware of our evil impulse, we may experience shame or guilt. 

 

Rather than reject the feelings and thoughts we experience as evil impulse, we need to acknowledge, and, indeed, even honor those feelings and thoughts. We need to embrace our feelings of shame and guilt.

 

Religions offer various forms of repentance and absolution, such as Catholic confession, Islamic Ramadan, and Jewish Yom Kippur rituals.  Can we face and embrace the feelings and thoughts of evil impulse without the need to confess or to seek absolution?  Can we accept ourselves?

 

Can we say, I hate, I envy, I lust, I covet, I am resentful, I am rebellious, I am greedy, I want to betray others, I want to betray my own values, and much more?

 

Yes, we distinguish between feelings/thoughts and action.  What if we know we have behaved badly?  Can we accept the feelings and thoughts that overwhelmed us and led to actions we wish we had not done?  Can we remain in touch with thoughts and feelings arising from the evil impulse and make efforts to refrain from actions we know we should not take?

 

Yes.  It is difficult, but necessary, if we are going to be whole. 

 

Psychiatrist and psychoanalyst Henry Krystal survived Treblinka concentration camp during the Holocaust.  Among his many books is “Integration and Self Healing: Affect, Trauma, and Alexithymia.” He worked with more than 100 camp survivors, including camp capos, who were camp inmates who were given positions of authority by the S.S.  Krystal found many capos to be self-loathing because of their identification with the aggressor, their abuse of their position at the expense of other inmates. Essentially he taught them that they could hate the deeds they committed, but they had to have love for the person who did those deeds, to understand the desperation and fear they experienced.  In essence, a version of hate the sin but love the sinner.  Concentration camps and similar places of oppression put people in extreme conditions.  Under extreme conditions, they very well may be overwhelmed by evil impulse.

 

Not every situation is as extreme, and not everything we do under the influence of the evil impulse is as dire.  Whatever the situation and the deed, ultimately we have to integrate who we are to remain psychically alive.

 

The good impulse will help us act wisely and ethically, so that we can remain a full, integrated human being, aware of, but not in thrall to, our selfishness, our evil impulse.

 

Love can prevail.

 

“If I am not for myself, who will be for me?  If I am only for myself,what am I?  And if not now, when?"

 

                          -- Rabbi Hillel, “Ethics of the Fathers

 

Categories: None

Post a Comment

Oops!

Oops, you forgot something.

Oops!

The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.

2924 Comments

Reply virukshamtrust
6:56 PM on October 2, 2022 
sac à main en jean scarpe mizuno trail running north sails giacca uomo rasmus dahlin jersey ipad 7th generation case with stand venice sneakers damen
virukshamtrust https://www.virukshamtrust.com/
Reply aldarakuae
6:56 PM on October 2, 2022 
zapatos lefties mujer 2021 mango blumenkleid zaino uomo guess von dutch cap pink brown nike air max command herren blau sombreros sol mujer
aldarakuae https://www.aldarakuae.com/
Reply mymobileappstores
6:56 PM on October 2, 2022 
mens polo beanie wanderschuhe adidas herren gorras de beisbol para bebes robe noir ou blanche strandkleid weiss mit stickerei kopp verlag handyhülle
mymobileappstores https://www.mymobileappstores.com/
Reply aeryhwryjdm
6:56 PM on October 2, 2022 
basket o bag black beanie zumiez lacoste high sneaker herren new era tienda en linea robe bohème amazon mittelalter kleid rot
aeryhwryjdm https://www.aeryhwryjdm.com/
Reply hbpmbz
6:56 PM on October 2, 2022 
snipers tienda zapatillas maglia lautaro martinez 1970s white dress sac de sport lakers nike tn plus 3 nere jeans diesel bambina
hbpmbz https://www.hbpmbz.com/
Reply frausieben
3:32 PM on October 2, 2022 
jd1 mid white shadow chain shirt dress germany euro 2020 kit lenado the north face nike x 270 nike team featherlight hat
frausieben http://www.frausieben.net/
Reply sukreni
10:48 AM on October 2, 2022 
oakland as digital camo hat knitting black western dress for women nhl all star jersey golden knights for cheap warriors nike dri fit nike dunk schwarz and rot uk brown shoes nike air max plus
sukreni http://www.sukreni.com/
Reply vampyrebatwings
3:57 PM on October 1, 2022 
gorro ruso mujer robe de mariée curvy edle hippie kleider weiß arktis iphone 12 hülle hülle für s20fe air jordan basse blanche
vampyrebatwings https://www.vampyrebatwings.com/
Reply kidslovepuzzles
3:57 PM on October 1, 2022 
tunique femme habillée pour mariage kleider auf rechnung kaufen hülle mit kette iphone 11 gravis ipad hülle asics noir rose ecco botas hombre
kidslovepuzzles https://www.kidslovepuzzles.com/
Reply rncguide
3:57 PM on October 1, 2022 
moschino borsa local beach visor adidas ryv herren gorra la negra robe en jeans tommy hilfiger street one kleider
rncguide https://www.rncguide.com/
Reply trustedwebcbd
3:57 PM on October 1, 2022 
birkenstock plateforme tenis under para dama benetton t shirt donna maternity wrap dress maxi portefeuille leopard femme prada infradito
trustedwebcbd https://www.trustedwebcbd.com/
Reply raspberrypihacks
3:56 PM on October 1, 2022 
samsung a51 otterbox amazon stiefeletten herbst jordan 1 red satin lacoste lerond schwarz zapatilla skechers en falabella c a lange sommerkleider
raspberrypihacks https://www.raspberrypihacks.com/
Reply kissmeflowers
10:43 AM on October 1, 2022 
air nike blanche tenis velez hombre pullover rosso uomo silk morning gown portefeuille homme cuir anti rfid nike air max 2090 donne
kissmeflowers https://www.kissmeflowers.com/
Reply shemcreekevents
10:43 AM on October 1, 2022 
robe patineuse bordeaux glitzerkleid kurz snipes handyhülle iphone xr hülle samsung 10 plus converse fleur plateforme sketcher falabella
shemcreekevents https://www.shemcreekevents.com/
Reply cofthriftstore
10:43 AM on October 1, 2022 
il portafoglio
cofthriftstore https://www.cofthriftstore.com/
Reply roboscholar
10:43 AM on October 1, 2022 
gorra negra mercedes benz robe manche longue mango peek und cloppenburg kinderkleider samsung s10 lite hülle leder samsung a50 hülle selbst gestalten reebok la haine noir
roboscholar https://www.roboscholar.com/
Reply mrwhiterabbit
10:42 AM on October 1, 2022 
xiaomi redmi note 8t phone case dachstein outdoorschuh skywalk lc nike air max grey yellow nike air max 90 herren schwarz weiß zapatos mujer suburbia kariertes kleid h m
mrwhiterabbit https://www.mrwhiterabbit.com/
Reply mazzacinema
9:19 PM on September 30, 2022 
lustige clogs jerry seinfeld nike shox puma cali sport grün los mejores tacos de futbol 2020 off shoulder kleid blau tracolla grande uomo
mazzacinema https://www.mazzacinema.com/
Reply aboutbabyshowers
9:19 PM on September 30, 2022 
leafs alternate jersey phone case samsung galaxy note 20 veja sneaker about you nb walking shoes womens adidas trekkingschuhe damen terrex rusty zapatillas
aboutbabyshowers https://www.aboutbabyshowers.com/
Reply jinteex
9:19 PM on September 30, 2022 
zaino personalizzato con iniziali brown plaid hat nike haifisch herren cachuchas planas robe de chambre armor lux romantische hochzeitskleider
jinteex https://www.jinteex.com/