Interactive Musings

Interactive Musings

The Evil Impulse

Posted on August 27, 2012 at 11:50 PM

THE EVIL IMPULSE

08/27/2012

 

Evil impulses are inherent in human nature, as are good impulses.

 

In Hebrew, the evil impulse is called yetzer ra, and the good impulse is called yetzer tov.  Acknowledging the existence of both impulses is essential to Jewish thought – as it is to Freudian psychoanalysis.  Freud postulated two drives inherent to human nature, eros and thanatos, a sexual drive and an aggressive drive. 

 

In religious tradition, the world is seen in terms of good and evil.  From a psychoanalytic standpoint, the impulses are not evaluated, nor judged for their moral or ethical essence.  Rather, they are acknowledged as aspects of human nature to be recognized, understood, and made conscious.

 

In Judaism, the emphasis is on choice.  Each person has the capability to choose to follow an evil impulse or a good impulse. 

 

In psychoanalysis, the emphasis is on self-knowledge, so that we do not act from the unconscious.  Rather, we become aware of our feelings, thoughts, conflicts, attitudes, desires, and memories, and our awareness creates opportunities for choices.  Rather than continue to be motivated by unconscious pressures, we have more personal power, the ability to act with self-awareness.

 

In Jewish thought, the evil impulse is selfishness without awareness of or concern for the impact of one’s actions on others.  Therefore we can understand sadism and violence as corruptions of the evil impulse, in a sense, extreme perversions of the evil impulse.  The evil impulse does not have to be denied, it has to be mitigated by loving concern, a kindly awareness of the experiences of others. 

 

Both Judaism and psychoanalysis offer the possibility of resolution of conflict, of reconciliation of one’s own selfishness, one’s own evil impulse, with one’s desire to think of ourselves as good.

 

Psychoanalysis enables us to understand that our desire to do something forbidden, something harmful, can be experienced, felt deeply, and transformed into something commensurate with the good impulse, without betraying our core self.

 

Our challenge is to embrace the evil impulse, to embrace and experience the feelings that give impetus to the evil impulse.

 

An important aspect of human nature is our capacity for self-reflection, and self-judgment.  One religious tradition calls self-reflection the Witness; psychoanalysis calls self-reflection observing ego.  Religions call self-judgment conscience; psychoanalysis calls self-judgment superego.  As we become aware of our evil impulse, we may experience shame or guilt. 

 

Rather than reject the feelings and thoughts we experience as evil impulse, we need to acknowledge, and, indeed, even honor those feelings and thoughts. We need to embrace our feelings of shame and guilt.

 

Religions offer various forms of repentance and absolution, such as Catholic confession, Islamic Ramadan, and Jewish Yom Kippur rituals.  Can we face and embrace the feelings and thoughts of evil impulse without the need to confess or to seek absolution?  Can we accept ourselves?

 

Can we say, I hate, I envy, I lust, I covet, I am resentful, I am rebellious, I am greedy, I want to betray others, I want to betray my own values, and much more?

 

Yes, we distinguish between feelings/thoughts and action.  What if we know we have behaved badly?  Can we accept the feelings and thoughts that overwhelmed us and led to actions we wish we had not done?  Can we remain in touch with thoughts and feelings arising from the evil impulse and make efforts to refrain from actions we know we should not take?

 

Yes.  It is difficult, but necessary, if we are going to be whole. 

 

Psychiatrist and psychoanalyst Henry Krystal survived Treblinka concentration camp during the Holocaust.  Among his many books is “Integration and Self Healing: Affect, Trauma, and Alexithymia.” He worked with more than 100 camp survivors, including camp capos, who were camp inmates who were given positions of authority by the S.S.  Krystal found many capos to be self-loathing because of their identification with the aggressor, their abuse of their position at the expense of other inmates. Essentially he taught them that they could hate the deeds they committed, but they had to have love for the person who did those deeds, to understand the desperation and fear they experienced.  In essence, a version of hate the sin but love the sinner.  Concentration camps and similar places of oppression put people in extreme conditions.  Under extreme conditions, they very well may be overwhelmed by evil impulse.

 

Not every situation is as extreme, and not everything we do under the influence of the evil impulse is as dire.  Whatever the situation and the deed, ultimately we have to integrate who we are to remain psychically alive.

 

The good impulse will help us act wisely and ethically, so that we can remain a full, integrated human being, aware of, but not in thrall to, our selfishness, our evil impulse.

 

Love can prevail.

 

“If I am not for myself, who will be for me?  If I am only for myself,what am I?  And if not now, when?"

 

                          -- Rabbi Hillel, “Ethics of the Fathers

 

Categories: None

Post a Comment

Oops!

Oops, you forgot something.

Oops!

The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.

3477 Comments

Reply Tommyhusly
4:05 AM on February 4, 2023 
antabuse pills
Reply Lisasnupt
9:48 PM on February 2, 2023 
buy stromectol uk
Reply Ivysnupt
5:59 PM on February 2, 2023 
fluoxetine uk allopurinol discount where can i get provigil albenza drug celebrex 200 mg tablet
Reply Ivysnupt
6:19 AM on February 2, 2023 
toradol for migraine diflucan 200 mg pill doxycycline 100mg tablet brand name vermox medication canadianpharmacy com 25 mg anafranil online reputable indian pharmacies
Reply kuenstlerkolonie
3:52 AM on February 2, 2023 
kaep dolphins hat for sale fox racing monster energy hats lids uk javier hernandez jersey for cheap washington nationals diamond era hat 2017 pandora 14k gold necklace converse looking shoes
kuenstlerkolonie http://www.kuenstlerkolonie.net/
Reply Joesnupt
1:29 AM on February 2, 2023 
malegra 100 toradol without prescription can you buy ventolin over the counter in singapore
Reply hdcamcrew
5:52 PM on February 1, 2023 
jordan hornets jersey le monde beryl mary jane moncler with hood turquoise coach purse basic long sleeve dress aq7488
hdcamcrew http://www.hdcamcrew.com/
Reply mathewslodge
11:32 AM on February 1, 2023 
pandora sparkling clip charm christian louboutin python seattle mariners mlb hat for sale cowboys dowdle pandora stackable heart ring lands end t shirt dress
mathewslodge http://www.mathewslodge.net/
Reply RichardHenly
10:44 AM on February 1, 2023 
metformin costs canada generic cialis canada online levitra 2.5mg cost keflex cream viagra online price usa
Reply Ivysnupt
8:25 AM on February 1, 2023 
buy vermox online usa buy dapoxetine pills diflucan without prescription 200mg where can i buy misoprostol over the counter ivermectin over the counter anafranil sale medicine xenical
Reply fatimahb
4:23 AM on February 1, 2023 
zach wilson white jersey rose lavelle uswnt jersey oakley frogskins prizm polarized lebron baseball blue new everton kit leaked for cheap air force 1 lv 08 noir
fatimahb http://www.fatimahb.com/
Reply Ivysnupt
8:49 AM on January 31, 2023 
400 mg acyclovir daily dapoxetine 30mg zoloft 75 how much is diflucan best online pharmacy india ciprofloxacin 250 tablet provigil mexico pharmacy
Reply sellergyllc
4:07 PM on January 30, 2023 
black polka dot dress zara youth nike panthers 70 trai turner blue alternate stitched nfl elite jersey elite calvin johnson womens jersey detroit lions 81 draft him shimmer pink nfl grey pink nike air more uptempo
sellergyllc http://www.sellergyllc.com/
Reply hoshinowa
8:10 AM on January 30, 2023 
purple 4s jordans modern western dress black classic doc martens rams hockey jersey new latest fashion dress hot honeymoon dress
hoshinowa http://www.hoshinowa.net/
Reply Ivysnupt
5:16 AM on January 30, 2023 
erythromycin without prescription safe canadian pharmacies
Reply transmn
6:14 PM on January 29, 2023 
peacocks ladies clothing long frocks party wear for ladies penze moncler iphone 11 pro max pink colour patriots white on white uniforms north face puffer jacket ebay
transmn http://www.transmn.net/
Reply Ivysnupt
2:05 PM on January 29, 2023 
how much is celebrex 100mg stromectol price albendazole buy uk ventolin free shipping bupropion xl 150mg cheapest doxycycline tablets canadapharmacyonline
Reply Robertbog
1:25 PM on January 29, 2023 
buy bupropion online cheap
Reply thinkeathealthy
10:45 AM on January 29, 2023 
nike kansas city chiefs jersey 76 branden albert red team color jersey youth elite nfl jersey sale liverpool fc champions hoodie classic leather mens shoes cp9685 army body warmer
thinkeathealthy http://www.thinkeathealthy.com/
Reply tiopepi
6:50 AM on January 29, 2023 
pandora jewelry heart necklace the hundreds hat rose 10 nike air jordan 14 black and grey nike dunk high prm sb diamond star wars hat knitting pattern new air jordan 31 red and red
tiopepi http://www.tiopepi.net/